Learn all about the evaluative essay and its components in.

free examples of essays, research and term papers.

Sample Thesis Statements for Evaluation Essays

Making an Argument
As stated earlier, the academic essay is an exercise in reasonedpersuasion. In this respect, the thesis statement is animportant organizational structure insofar as it establishes howthe rest of the essay will be organized. Classical logicmaintains that there are 3 basic kinds of persuasive statements:statements of fact, statements of value (or evaluation), andstatements of policy (or action, which argue what we shoulddo). Unless otherwise specified, the first of these, thestatement of fact, is the form that the thesis statement for anacademic essay should take–the obvious exception being whenyou write evaluative criticism (which you will NEVER do in mycourse).

Evaluation Essays: Thesis Statements

But try this: "As her use of language shows, Moll Flanders imagines every aspect of life, including love and family life, in economic terms." A bit better, but still boring. It leaves me asking, "So what? Who cares if Moll Flanders imagines everything in economic terms?" The thesis is better than the first example, but try making it better by asking yourself the "so what?" question.

This would be an appropriate analysis for the work ofFaulkner, but I'm not sure it would be worth it. To beginwith, it is not clear what the writer has to gain in terms ofproving BOTH of these aspects of the work rather than just theone. Instead, with this complex thesis, there are going to belong sections of the essay where half of what needs to be provedwill be left suspended while the other half getsdiscussed. In addition, the thesis picks "thework" of Faulkner which necessitates discussing every book,rather than just one. Thus it is that an importantconvention of the academic essay is that:

The impossible thesis statement is a kind of corollary ofthe banal thesis statement insofar as you want to stay away fromit. Rather than saying something which is evident ormeaningless, however, the impossible thesis statement putsforward something which cannot reasonably be proved, as a resultof there being no agreed upon or stable criteria from which torender conclusions. Examples of impossible statementsabound, but the one most related to this course would be "ThePlague is great art," or "The Plague isthe most realistic of all Camus' novels." In eachcase, there is no stable criteria. Take the firstone. What distinguishes between "good" art and"great" art? Furthermore, the essay would not beable to point to a stable definition of "art", aconcept that art historians, artists, and cultural critics havebeen arguing over for centuries. The latter thesis has asimilar problem since "realistic" is not a stableconcept with firm criteria.


evaluative thesis statement evaluative essay

This handout describes what a thesis statement is, how thesis statements work in your writing, and how you can help with paper discover or refine one for your draft Hiqpdf evaluation essay.

Evaluative thesis statement - Scottish Research Society

You , however, evaluate him by standards that came him: "Whitman's content appears more experimental, even radical, because his form is also revolutionary; the form and content work together to challenge conventional wisdom." This revision is the best example of working toward making a strong thesis. The way to make it even stronger would be to carry out the final idea a bit more. "......to challenge conventional wisdom, which stated that......." What was the conventional wisdom that Whitman's work challenged?

Evaluative essay thesis statement - AJFMAQUINARIA

Other printable documents: Mla research essay outline template keyword essay evaluation thesis statement in essay an on importance of educational tour in ….

Essay Evaluative thesis statement ..

Establishing Criteria
In the discussion of types of argument, I made the point that thewriter will have to establish criteria that can be used to provetheir argument. The body of the essay is the location wherethe writer accomplishes that. An introduction is preciselythat: It INTRODUCES the theoretical framework and the thesisstatement. It does not DESCRIBE or DISCUSS these twothings. This is a fairly common mistake that beginningessay writers make. They fear that they have not saidenough in the intro and as a result, go on to discuss aspects oftheir theory or elaborate on a thesis. The problem withdoing so is that it screws up your organization. What comes nextis no longer clear to the reader.

Evaluation essay thesis: how to write

A simple thesis statement is not quite what it maysound like. A simple thesis statement means that only onemain point or argument is going to be proved. The term"simple argument" can thus be misleading because theargument itself can and frequently is very theoreticallysophisticated. What makes them simple is that in terms oftheir logical structure, they only take on one line of proof, andhence, their organization of proof will be simple. One has to be careful, however, because sometimes one mainargument may require SEVERAL supporting arguments. Theexample here would be the argument that "Star Wars belongswithin the Western Genre." Here the writer has onlyone thing to prove, but in order to do so will have to establishthe elements that comprise the Western Genre and demonstrate howthe film embodies them--not a small task.